Skip to main content

Full text of "On the Structure of Gold-Leaf, and the Absorption Spectrum of Gold"

See other formats


[ 43 ] 



11. On the Structure of Gold-Leaf and the Absorption Spectrum of Gold> 

By J. W. Mallet, BIRS., Professor of Chemistry in- the University 

of Virginia, 

ReceiTed May 22,— Read June 11, 1903. 

JL IjA 1 L J. . 

GoLD4eaf, as seen under the microscope by transmitted light, presents a remarkable 
appearance which seems to have been hitherto either not at all or only slightly 
noticed. The colour of the transmitted light is bluish-green, unless silver in 
considerable proportion be alloyed with the gold; in this latter case the colour is 
purpHsh-blue. The amount of light transmitted is, as might be expected, not uniform, 
the thickness of the gold film varying within very small areas of the surface. All 
this is well known to anyone who has ever looked through a bit of the leaf 

But, in addition, numerous black lines are visible under very moderate amplification, 
ramifying irregularly over the surface, here and there showing some tendency to 
parallelism, but for the most part running into each other in the most irregular way. 
Fig. 1^ illusfcrates this; it is a microscopic photograph of ordinary commercial gold- 
leaf, taken with an amplification of 75 diameters, and a distance from the eye-piece to 
the camera plate of 378 millims. 

In Faraday's Bakerian lecture, read before the Eoyal Society on February 5, 1857, 
on the "Experimental Eelations of Gold (and other metals) to Light,"t there occur 
two or three sentences which prove that this peculiar appearance did not escape his 
keen observation. For example, he says " when the thicker parts of the leaf were 
examined they seemed to be accumulated plications of the gold, the leaf appearing as 
a most irregular and crumpled object, with dark veins running across both the thicker 
and thinner parts, and from one to the other." Again, referring to specimens of gold- 
leaf which had been heated in oil, he says " it will be seen that it is the thicker folds 
and parts of the mottled mass that retain the original state longest.'' And again he 
remarks, '' there is a little difficulty in admitting that such an irregular corrugated 
film as gold-leaf appears to be, can possess any general compression in one direction 

^ All of the microscopic pliotographs referred to in this paper have been presented to the Royal Society, 
but only Nos. 4, 6, and 8 have been reproduced for publication. 
t *PhiL Trans.,' 1857, pp. 145-181, 
VOL, CCIIL-^A 360. G 2 29.1.04 



44 PROFESSOR J. W. MALLET ON THE STRUCTURE OF GOLD LEAF, 

only." But Faraday does not seem to have specially investigated the peculiarity in 
question, or its cause, and, in view of the process by which gold is extended into 
these thin films, the terms '' plications " and " folds " which he uses must be xuiderstood 
as referring to the appearance only of the leaf and not to its actual structure. 

The idea first suggested by the ramification and reticulation of black lines was that 
they might depend in some way on the crystalline structure of the alloyed gold used 
for making commercial gold-leaf, modified and distorted during the process of beating. 
Hence specimens of gold-leaf variously alloyed were compared with each other. The 
following samples were furnished me by the manufacturers, the W. H. Kemp Company, 
of 165, Spring Street, New York, with a statement of their composition : — 

A. Dark or red gold-leaf, made with an addition of 18 grains of copper to each 

Troy ounce (480 grains) of pure gold, or, more strictly, gold assaying about 
998-999 fine. 

B. Gold-leaf of medium colour, made with an addition of 12 grains of copper and 

12 grains of silver to each Troy ounce of fine gold. 

c. Pale or light-coloured gold-leaf, made with an addition of 6 pennyweights 
(144 grains) of silver to the Troy ounce of fine gold. 

Figs. 1, 2, and 3 show the appearance of these three samples respectively under 
the amplification already mentioned for No. 1, which represents the gold alloyed with 
copper only, No. 2 that containing both copper and silver, and No. 3 that containing 
silver only. The three exhibit some difierences, bu^t not much greater than are 
presented by different samples of leaf of the same composition, and the general 
character is evidently the same. In consequence of the small amount of light 
transmitted by the leaf, exposures of the photographic plates for two or three miimtes 
were necessary, and changes in the state of the sky and character of the light during 
this time prevent the photographs giving quite a correct idea of the different degrees 
of translucency of the specimens. Owing probably to slight shaking of the floor 
affecting the position of the camera, the ramified lines do not appear quite as sharp 
and well defined as when viewed directly through the eye-piece of the microscope. 

It was desirable to see whether the same appearance, if referable in any way to the 
original molecular structure of the metal, would present itself in leaf beaten from 
pure gold free from all alloy. On applying to two firms of gold-beaters — one in 
New York and the other in Philadelphia —to make for me a small quantity of leaf 
from fine gold, I was assured by both that it was impossible to beat pure gold thin 
enough to be seen through. Dentists' gold foil could be had, but it is quite opaque. 
The reasons assigned for the difficulty were the excessive tendency of the pure gold 
to cohere, so that it could not be manipulated without different parts touching each, 
other and sticking together, and also the tendency of the pure metal to stick to the 
''gold-beaters skin" or animal membrane used to separate the leaves in beating. 



AND THE ABSOEPTION SPICTBUM OF GOLD. 45 

After a good deal of persuasion I succeeded in inducing the manager of the 
W. H. Kemp Company — Mr. W. R. Hanna — to try the experiment of beating into 
leaf, as thin as could be had, a sample of fine gold which I sent him. This was 
'' proof gold" from the assay department of the United States Mint at Philadelphia, 
and therefore of the highest attainable purity. The result was quite satisfactory for 
the intended purpose, though it would not have been so in a commercial sense, there 
being a good deal of waste, and many torn leaves and large holes. The microscopic 
appearance of this pure gold-leaf is shown in fig. 4 (Plate 1). It is in general like 
the commercial specimens, but the lines are bolder and more strongly defined — a 
consequence, as I think will be shown, of the greater softness of the pure metal. 

Study of these microscopic appearances, and comparison of them with each other 
and with the micro-photographs of Osmond, Roberts- Austen, Arnold, Andrews 
and others, did not seem to support the idea that the lines in question are due to 
more or less distorted crystalline structure. In order to learn whether the lines are 
to be referred to, and originate in, the process of gold-beating by which the leaves 
have been produced, the attempt was made to obtain galvanically-deposited films of 
something like the same thickness, so that these latter might be microscopically 
examined by transmitted light. 

Pieces of thin rolled silver foil, much larger than would be needed for microscopical 
examination only, were varnished on one side and then electrolytically coated with 
fine gold on the. other, using a specially prepared pure cyanide solution and an anode 
of fine gold. As there was no guide by which to determine in advance the thickness 
of the gold film which would admit of being satisfactorily seen through, the current 
was passed for various periods of time, producing films of several different thicknesses, 
and, after the subsequent treatment, one or two were selected which gave the best 
results. About a square centimetre cut from each piece of foil was well washed with 
ether to free it from varnish, and was then cemented- — ^the gilded face downwards — 
upon a slide of thin microscope cover glass by means of Canada balsam somewhat 
diluted with ether. After time had been afforded for the balsam to harden, the silver 
was dissolved off* slowly by very dilute nitric acid, and the gold film was ready for 
microscopic examination. Fig. 5 shows the appearance presented, the amplification 
and distance from eye-piece to camera plate being the same as for fig. 1 and for all 
the other microscopic illustrations of this paper. It is evident that the mottled 
structure of this film, showing varying thickness, is unaccompanied by the ramifica- 
tions of well defined black lines to be seen in beaten gold-leaf. No attention should 
be given to the two large bars of shadow crossing each other at right angles in this 
photograph ; they are due to the shadow of a part of the window sash having been 
inadvertently allowed to fall on the illuminating mirror of the microscope. 

To test whether the black lines are really due to minute threads or wires of gold 
with diameters considerably greater than the thickness of those parts of the leaf 
which can be seen through, it was proposed to protect a piece of gold-leaf by placing 



46 PROFESSOK J. W. MALLET ON THE STRUOTUEE OF GOLD-LEAF, 

it between two sheets of silver foil, roll the whole down to a fraction of the original 
thickness, remove the silver by means of nitric acid, and see whether the lines in the 
gold had been broadened out by flattening of the wire-like threads if present. A 
rectangular piece of fine silver foil, *019 millim. thick, was folded in two across the 
middle of its length, a piece of the " fine'' gold4eaf which had been specially beaten 
for me by the W. H. Kemp Company was spread out flat between the two folds of 
silver, and then by the same firm the whole rolled down until the double thickness, 
'038 millim., had been reduced to '006 millim. Care was taken to introduce the 
folded edge first between the rolls, so as to prevent as far as possible slipping of one 
surface of foil upon the other. Examination with nitric acid of dififerent parts of the 
roUed-down foil showed that, although there had been no small tearing of the gold 
and many holes had been produced in it, there were quite sufficient areas of it left in 
a practically continuous state. Assuming that the gold had been rolled out pari 
■passu with the silver, each had been reduced to something like one-sixth or one- 
seventh of the original thickness. 

A small piece of the foil in this condition was varnished on one side, and the other 
side stripped of silver by very dilute nitric acid, A number of specimens were spoiled 
at this stage, since the acid getting through any holes would attack the silver on the 
other side and eat its way between the varnish and the gold film, which was so 
exceedingly thin as not to bear any manipulation when unsupported. A few good 
specimens, however, were secured. These were cleared of varnish by soaking in 
ether, cemented by the gold face with diluted Canada balsam to slips of thin 
microscope cover glass, and, after hardening of the balsam, the second film of silver 
was gradually removed by very dilute nitric acid. Fig. 6 (Plate 1), representing, 
under the same amplification as in the other figures, the microscopic appearance of 
one of these specimens of rolled-down pure gold-leaf, exhibits very distinctly the 
flattening out of the minute metallic threads, favoured by the greater softness of the 
fi^old than of the silver which enclosed it. 

As a further test of the black lines being due to minute wires or threads of gold, 
specimens of the fine gold4eaf w^ere thinned down by partial solution, in order to see 
whether the lines would remain visible longer than the general surface of the leaf, 
and the thicker lines longer than the more delicate. The solvent used was a ^ per 
cent, aqueous solution of potassium cyanide, to which had been added a little 
hydrogen dioxide. The result is shoAvn in fig. 7, and in fig. 8 (Plate 1), the former 
of these representing a less, and the latter a more, advanced stage of the solvent 
attack upon the leaf. The more gradual obliteration of the black lines than of the 
rest of the surface is quite apparent. 

As it seemed to be established that the black lines under examination represent 
microscopic threads or wires, and that these are developed in the gold during the 
process of beating, it was natural to look for their possible origin in some correspond- 
ing peculiarity of structure in the " gold-beaters' skin" or animal membrane between 



AND THE ABSORPTION SPECTRUM OP GOLD. 47 

sheets of which the leaves of gold are extended. But this idea is not borne out by 
microscopic study of that material. The thin gold foil with which the process is 
begun is first beaten for about twenty minutes only between surfaces of ^^cutch^^ 
paper, which has simply the structure of a felted mass of vegetable fibres. The 
principal extension of the gold is brought about by beating for about four hours in a 
'' shoder" or packet of leaves of old or previously often used gold-beaters' skin, the 
packet, containing a thousand leaves, being from time to time bent betw^een the 
fingers to loosen the gold films and prevent their sticking to the membrane, and 
finally by beating for another four hours in a '^ mould" or similarly made up packet 
of leaves of new or much less used gold-beaters' skin, repeating the bending of the 
packet to maintain the looseness of the gold films. The cutch is beaten with 
hammers of about sixteen pounds in weight, striking about sixty blows a minute, the 
shoder with hammers of about ten pounds and at the rate of about seventy-five blows 
per minute, and the mould with six-pound hammers and at the rate of about ninety 
blows per minute. Figs. 9, 10, and 11 represent respectively the cutch paper, the 
already much used gold-beaters' skin of the shoder, and the new, or nearly new, skin 
of the mould. There is nothing in any of these to account for the black lines seen in 
the gold-leaf. As far as any distant resemblance to these is suggested by some of 
the vegetable fibres in fig. 9, it is to be remembered that fibres in relief would 
produce in the gold corresponding furrows, appearing as lines of greater, not less, 
translucency than that of the rest of the surface. The animal membrane or gold- 
beaters' skin in which by far the greater part of the beating is done, including all the 
later part of the work, exhibits in figs. 10 and 11 the simple and nearly uniform 
structure of the serous coat of the intestine — said to be the caecum — of the ox which 
is used for the purpose. 

A careful personal inspection of the process of gold-beating at the establishment of 
the W. H. Kemp Company in New York, has led me to the belief that the production 
of the ramified lines of microscopic wires or threads in the gold-leaf is due to the 
following cause. The face of the hammer used is slightly convex, and hence a blow 
struck with it tends to stretch each sheet of gold, and the animal membrane enclosing 
it, outwards in all directions from the centre of impact. The membrane is elastic and 
not absolutely uniform in thickness or tensile strength. Hence it tends to form, 
along lines of weakness, wrinkles running irregularly outwards, such as may be 
produced in any stretched piece of cloth by a push of the finger in any given 
direction. These wrinkles constitute microscopic troughs or furrows into which 
the soft gold is driven, forming corresponding rods or wires of extremely minute 
size. The elasticity of the membrane leads to the momentarily developed wrinkles 
being almost instantly obliterated, while the plasticity of the gold admits of no 
corresponding disappearance of the wire-like threads produced. The complicated 
ramification of the lines is no doubt due in part to the irregular distribution of lines 
of weakness, and therefore of easy stretching, in the membrane, partly to the blows 



48 PROFESSOR J. W. MALLET ON THE STRUCTURE OF GOLD-LEAF, 

of the hammer falling in rapid succession upon different adjacent parts of the surface, 
and partly to the lack of uniformity of support given by the other leaves above and 
below in the packet. The view now stated receives confirmation from a point 
strongly insisted upon by Mr. Hanna— the very intelligent superintendent of the 
W. H. Kemp Company's workshops — namely, that for success in the gold-beating 
process much depends on the condition of the animal membrane as to moisture or 
dryness. If it be very dry the gold-leaf cracks or breaks^ while if the membrane be 
too moist the leaf sticks to it. The membrane requires to be dried or dampened to 
correct the opposite effects of change in the atmosphere^ This accords with the idea 
that a certain amount of elastic stretching of the membrane, from which this 
recovers, is necessary for the permanent or inelastic extension of the gold. In fact, 
as the area of the gold-leaf is permanently extended by the beating, while that of 
the membrane is not, the one film manifestly must slide over the other. It is 
scarcely conceivable that this sliding shall occur at the moment at which a blow 
falls, when friction between the surfaces is at a maximum If not, it must occur 
just afterwards, as a result of the elastic resilience of the membrane, which leaves 
behind it the plastic gold. 

It is evident that the statements to be found in the books as to the actual thickness 
of gold-leaf — based as they are upon weighing of measured areas — -represent only 
average thickness, and that, in view of the decidedly greater thickness of these 
microscopic threads of gold running through the mass than of the intervening parts, 
the thickness of these latter parts must be notably less than the average. The 
following determinations were carefully made with several square decimetres of leaf 
in each case, accurately measured as to area, and weighed on a delicate assay balance. 
The results are stated in ^' microns " (thousandths of a millimetre). 

Average thickness. 
Commercial gold-leaf, alloyed with copper only, represented by Fig. 1 'OZOT/x 

copper and silver ,, ,? 2 •0822/x 

silver only ,, ?? 3 'OOST/x 

Gold-leaf specially beaten from '^ fine'^ gold ,, ,, 4 *1082/x 

A galvanically deposited film of ''fine" gold „ „ 5 *1263/x 

Maximum thickness of '' fine " gold film which can be seen 

through— -about ...»,.«...,.«...* *2000/x 

Dentists' ''fine" gold foil ............... '9228ft 

In connection with the microscopic examination of gold films by transmitted light, 
it seemed to be interesting to make some observations on the absorption spectrum of 
the metal, especially as there have been recently published the results of spectroscopic 
study of the light which the metal reflects. 

It was proposed to examine for this purpose metallic gold in the following forms :— 

1. Pure or " fine" gold-leaf. 



?? J3 ?J 

>J J? ?? 



AND THE ABSORPTION SPECTEIJxM OF GOLD. 49^ 

2. Gold chemically reduced in a dilute aqueous solution of its chloride — so-called 

colloidal gold — the metal being in sufficient quantity and state of aggrega- 
tion to transmit greenish-blue light. 

3. Ditto, a less amount of more finely distributed gold transmitting ruby-red 

light. 

4. Glass coloured by gold so as to transmit greenish-blue light — the so-called 

saphirine glass. 

5. Glass coloured ruby-red by very finely divided gold. 

It was found to be impracticable to secure any result for the gold-leaf, on account 
of the very small amount of light transmitted. For the colloidal gold in water, and 
the gold-coloured glass, the following results were obtained. 



Visible Spectrum, 

The source of light was a strong electric arc between closely placed carbon poles, 
with a slit of about ^ millim. in width. Dispersion was obtained by a Rowland 
concave grating of 21*5 feet focal length, ruled with about 15,000 lines to the inch, 
using the spectrum of the first order. The photographs were taken on M. A. Seed 
dry plates ('' orthochromatic, L"), specially sensitized for the region from green to 
red inclusive. The original photographs were laid side by side, so that the positions 
of like wave-lengths were the same for all, and then re-photographed together on a 
reduced scale. The results are shov/n in fig. 12, with a few positions indicated in 
Angstrom units. 

Taking the strips in order from the top downwards, the first (uppermost) strip 
represents the light transmitted simply through a sheet, about 2 millims. thick, of 
colourless glass of the same kind as that on which the gold ruby-red is '' flashed,^' and 
which also formed the end plates of cells containing the colloidal gold in aqueous 
suspension — time of exposure about 2 minutes — ^the darkness at the less refrangible 
end is due, not to absorption, but to the insensitiveness of the photographic film for 
rays in this region. The second strip shows the efiect of transmission through a 
column of water, 2*25 centims. long, containing 75 milligs. of metallic gold to the 
litre, reduced from the chloride by potassium acid carbonate and formic aldehyde, 
and exhibiting dark greenish-blue colour— time of exposure 30 minutes. The third 
represents also colloidal gold in watery suspension, but in a column of 9*25 centims. 
long, with 50 milligs. of gold per litre, and showing a blue or slightly violet-blue 
colour — time of exposure 20 minutes. The fourth represents the same, in a column 
of same length as the last, but with only 20 milligs. of gold per litre, and showing a 
clear ruby-red colour — time of exposure 10 minutes. The fifth, shifted ove^r to the 
right to secure correspondence of position for equal wave-lengths, is the same as the 
first, but with shorter exposure ; the right-hand end is in the region of slight 

VOL. CCIII.^ — A. H 



50 PEOFESSOE J, W. MALLET ON THE STEUCTUEE OF GOLD-^-LEAP, 

sensitiveness of the film. The sixth (lowermost) strip shows the result of trans- 
mission through the ^'flashed" ruhy-red glass, with very long exposure — -1 hour and 
10 minutes. 

In these photographs there is no indication of well defined absorption bands. The 
general absorption belongs mainly to the middle portion of the spectrum, and is, on 
the whole, more marked at the less refrangible end, with notable increase of 
absorption in this region as the amount of gold present is increased. The position of 
maximum absorption is nearer to the lons'-wave end for the siass than for the 
colloidal gold in water. It is interesting to note that, while no photographed results 
could be obtained from the saphirine glass, the absorption being too far in the red for 
the sensitiveness of the film, eye observation of this glass, using sunlight and a glass- 
prism spectroscope, showed a distinct belt of absorption extending from about 5700 
to 6250, beside the general absorption of rays of shorter vfave-length. Allowance 
has to be made in the photographs for insensitiveness of the film at the red end of 
the spectrum. 

Ultra-violet Spectrum, 

This was examined with a quartz prism, and for the liquids a tube closed at the 
ends by plates of quartz. The source of light was electric sparks between cadmium 
poles placed pretty near each other. The results are shown in figs, 13, 14 and 15, a 
few of the positions being indicated by the wave-lengths of the cadmium lines, as 
before. No results could be obtained for the saphirine or the ruby glass, the glass 
alone absorbing all rays in the ultra violet. Fig. 13 represents the water with 
colloidal gold in suspension, 75 milligs. to the litre, in a column of 2 '2 5 centims. long. 
Fig. 14 represents a like liquid, with 50 milligs. per litre, and in a column 9*25 
.centims. long. Fig. 15 is the same, with 20 milligs. per litre, and in a column 
also 9 '2 5 centims. long. 

In each of these three figures the three uppermost strips represent exposures for 
3, 5 and 10 minutes respectively (counting from above downwards), the light passing 
through the colloidal gold liquid, while the four lower strips exhibit the results from 
.sparks through air (no gold hquid interposed) for 1, 2, 5 and 10 seeonds respectively. 
The general absorption, withouit indication of dark bands, begins to be well marked 
at about 3500, and increases toward the more refrangible portion of the spectrum, the 
efi:ect increasing also with the amount of gold present. 

Infra-red Spectrimi, 

This was examined, by the obliging permission of Professor S. P. Langley, 
Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C., in the astrophysical 
laboratory of that institution, using sunlight, a rock-salt prism, and Professor 



AND THE ABSORPTION SPECTRUM OF GOLD, 51 

Langlby's bolometer with ]3hotographic auto-registration of the results. These 
results were in sfeneral as follows :— 

The specimen of ruby-red gold glass almost totally absorbs the light of the short- 
wave-length side of D, rapidly increases to the full transparency of the ordinary 
colourless (unflashed) glass at about A, and continues as transparent as this ordinary 
glass to about 2'5fjL. The saphirine or blue glass coloured by gold, cuts off the light 
to near C, then rises very rapidly to great transparency at and beyond A. 

The red colloidal gold liquid No. 1, 20 milHgs. metallic gold per litre, contained in 
a cell with end plates of thin microscope glass, 4*5 centims. apart, produces great 
general absorption in the visible spectrum, though not reaching to the point of 
completely, or almost completely, extinguishing any rays included within the region 
of spectrum studied, as was the case with the glass specimens. The absorption of 
this liquid becomes practically identical with that of distilled water at and beyond A. 

The violet-blue colloidal gold liquid No. 2, 50 milligs. gold per litre, and the 
greenish-blue liquid No. 3, 75 milligs. gold per litre, behave on the whole like liquid 
No. 1, except that they diminish the radiations throughout the spectrum to a very 
great extent, as if by the interposition of opaque obstacles to the rays. Liquid No. 3 
appears relatively less transparent in the visible spectrum, besides being generally 
less transparent throughout the spectrum. 

I regret that the blue-print tracings of the bolometer curves are so faint as not to 
allow of photographic reproduction on a reduced scale. 

For the microscopic and spectroscopic photographs I have to thank the kind 
assistance of Professor A. H. Tuttle and Dr. W. J. Humphreys of this University^ 



■i-i^ 



J, W. Mallet 



Phil, Trans,, xi, voL 203, Plate 1.